You’re looking at installing a new security gate for the entrance of your commercial property and you’re faced with two options—manual and automatic. 

Which one do you choose? Each one comes with different benefits and drawbacks. You may want something easy to operate and maintain. Perhaps security is your greatest priority. In this blog, we’ll go over the pros and cons of automatic and manual gates so you can make a more informed choice. 

Manual Gates

Manual gates are gates that open without any automatic, electronic assistance. They are a traditional option that is perfect for commercial properties that value simplicity and cost-effectiveness. 

Manual gates are available in two styles—swing gates and slide gates. 

Pros

There are many benefits to manual gates, including:

• They Have a Lower Initial Investment—manual gates are less complex, which means they have a lower upfront cost. No expensive electronic components or automation technology are required, which also means that the installation costs are less.
• They’re Much Simpler—the key advantage of manual gates lies in their simplicity. With no electronic components, there’s less risk of system failure, making them a low-maintenance, dependable solution for basic access control. That said, if convenience, automation, or advanced security features are priorities for your property, an automatic gate may offer greater long-term value.
• They’re Not Dependent on Power—thanks to their manual nature, manual gates are not vulnerable to power outages. That makes them a much more reliable option than automatic gates that are dependent on power.
• Quick and Cost-Effective to Install—manual gates offer a straightforward installation process, making them faster and more budget-friendly to set up. While professional installation is still essential to ensure proper alignment and reliable performance, the overall cost is typically lower than that of automated systems.

Cons

However, manual gates have their drawbacks, such as:

• They Are Less Convenient—the primary drawback of a manual gate is that it needs to be opened and closed manually. This is far less convenient, especially in rain or snow. Additionally, the physical effort may create accessibility issues to enter.
• They Have Security Limitations—manual gates don’t have as robust security as automatic gates. The lack of access control systems makes it easier for unauthorized people to gain access to your property.
• They Often Have Fewer Features—manual gates often lack the many features that you can get in automatic gates. Remote access, intercom systems, and integrated cameras are all unavailable, which limits the amount of control you have. 

Automatic Gates

Automatic gates are more complex than manual gates. They are powered by a motor that is controlled by a remote access system or a sensor. They offer many features that are great if you prioritize security and convenience.

Automatic gates are available in swinging, sliding, bi-folding, and cantilever models. 

Pros

Automatic gates have a wide range of benefits, such as:

• They’re Convenient—one of the biggest advantages of automatic gates is the ability to enter or exit without leaving your vehicle — especially useful during harsh weather or late-night arrivals. With options like remote controls, keypads, and smartphone app integration, operating your gate is quick, seamless, and secure.
• They Offer Enhanced Security—with a variety of built-in safety and monitoring features, automatic gates provide much greater security than manual gates. Many models may include electronic locks, motion detectors, cameras, and intercom systems. Plus, automatic gate systems lock the gate after use, reducing the likelihood of human error.
• You’ll Increase Your Property Value—an automatic gate is a desirable feature to have on a property. Installing one for your commercial property can greatly improve your property’s value thanks to the added security and luxury that a gate brings.
• They’re Very Customizable—automatic gates are available in different designs, materials, and finishes. You can choose a gate that suits the aesthetics of your property while still meeting your operational needs.
• Safety Features are Available—modern automatic gates are equipped with a variety of safety features that help prevent costly accidents. These features can include photo sensors, a separate entrance for pedestrians, and more. 

Cons

Automatic gates have their share of cons. These include:

• Higher Initial Investment—automatic gates require a much higher upfront investment than manual gates, both in terms of the purchase of the gate itself and the installation. As a more complex gate that includes the automation system, plus keypads, cameras, or intercoms, it requires more specialized installers.
• Required Maintenance and Repairs—automatic gates require more regular maintenance to ensure that their motors, sensors, and electronic components function correctly. Breakdowns can be costly, especially if the warranty has expired.
• Power Dependent—automatic gates require continuous power to operate. That leaves them vulnerable and inoperable in the event of a power disruption.
• They Consume Energy—because they are dependent on power to operate, automatic gates can lead to higher energy bills. This is especially true if your gate has added features such as cameras or lights.
• Complex Installation Process—thanks to the many different electronic and automatic systems, the installation of an automatic gate is more difficult and time-consuming than a manual gate. Professional installation is needed to ensure everything is set up properly. 

Manual or Automatic, Creative Door Services Has the Commercial Gate You Need

Whether you’re leaning toward a manual gate or prefer the convenience of an automated system, Creative Door Services has the right solution for your commercial property. We provide expert installation, reliable maintenance, and responsive repair services—so your facility stays secure and your gate continues to perform for years to come.

Contact us today to learn more about our commercial gate solutions. We’re happy to serve you from one of our eight locations across Western Canada in Kelowna, British Columbia; Vancouver, British Columbia; Calgary, Alberta; Edmonton, Alberta; Fort McMurray, Alberta; Regina, Saskatchewan; Saskatoon, Saskatchewan; and Winnipeg, Manitoba.